How to make an angry editor

You start with multiple typos in a single sentence, like this from Yahoo! Shine:

Then you take a recipe from another source (like the popular Web site Cravings) and neglect to give it credit. In the process of “borrowing” the recipe, you mistake 3 pounds of lobster with 3-pound lobsters. And finally, you fail to “borrow” the entire instructions. As bad as those errors are, nothing infuriates an editor more than unattributed text.

About these ads

11 Responses to “How to make an angry editor”

  1. what would you do without us? Says:

    Thank God for you, Terribly Write! More free edits! Yahoo should hire you! (Oh, wait, they already did, didn’t they? I’m so glad you found a new gig.)

  2. Kathleen Says:

    Perhaps Yahoo should focus on quality writing and editing before posting and relying on a blogger to point out errors. It’s not like these errors take a lot of time to check.

  3. what would you do without us? Says:

    Oh, to walk a mile in another man’s shoes…
    In any case, I thank my lucky stars for a free service like this one. It’s such an educational tool–we can learn from this blogger and change our terrible mistakes in real time. It’s the best.

  4. Jerry Says:

    Agreed! It’s a great blog that I like to check daily (sometimes more than once). Glad you like it too, Jennifer.

  5. CuriousGeorge Says:

    I don’t read this blog very often, but now that I see how much vitriole this blogger has stirred up, I’ll be back more frequently. You’d think that the writers over at yahoo would be embarrassed by all their errors, but instead they are defensive!!! Keep up the good work, Laura! It’s good to know that there are people like you with some standards for accuracy and good, correct writing. Too bad yahoo doesn’t share them.

  6. Annette Cardwell Says:

    Actually, Laura, this recipe was pitched to us by the restaurant, and apparently the PR rep pitched it to more than just us. We didn’t steal this recipe from Cravings. We are very careful to not take content from any site or blog without attribution.

  7. Old Man Says:

    If “what would you do without us?” really is “Jennifer,” I can understand the defensiveness. He/she/it has much to be defensive about.

    Apparently Yahoo! Shine lacks class as well as writing skills.

  8. Laura Says:

    Annette,

    Thank you for clarifying this for me. I found it hard to believe that it would be taken from an unattributed source. But it looks like Cravings got a bit more of the recipe and that the instructions are definitely different. Not that I intend to try it — what with the 3-pound lobsters or 3 pounds of lobster.

  9. Annette Cardwell Says:

    Totally understand. This took us by surprise. Also, we miss you very much at Yahoo! :) Obviously, we’re lacking copy edit resources and are trying to make the best of it.

  10. Professor Plum Says:

    Glad to hear the response from Annette. A much more professional post from Yahoo than that smack from Jennifer. I’m encouraged to hear that they don’t swipe content without attribution. Editing would be a good touch to add, though.

  11. TW Fan Says:

    Dear what would you do without us?,

    You mention that changing your terrible mistakes in real time is “the best.” You know what’s even better? Being educated enough in your professional field not to make them in the first place.


What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 785 other followers

%d bloggers like this: